top of page

Think You Made Too Much for a Health Insurance Subsidy? How to Cut the Bill in 2026

11 minutes ago
5 min read

If your health insurance bill jumped this year, you are not imagining it. The extra premium subsidies expired at the end of 2025, and Congress has not brought them back.

The subsidy that remains depends on one number on your tax return, and you have more control over that number than you might think. Here is the short version.


Covered through your job? Good for you

If you get health insurance through work, you are in the simplest spot. The Marketplace subsidy is not meant for you, and most of this post does not apply.

One thing to check: if your work plan is HSA-eligible, fund the HSA through payroll. Money that goes in that way skips income tax and also Social Security and Medicare tax.


The Health Savings Account

An HSA is a savings account for medical costs with three tax breaks. The contribution is deductible, the money grows tax-free, and withdrawals for medical costs are tax-free.

For 2026 you can put in:

  • $4,400 with self-only coverage

  • $8,750 with family coverage

  • An extra $1,000 if you are 55 or older


You need an HSA-eligible health plan. New for 2026, every bronze and catastrophic Marketplace plan qualifies. Silver and gold plans qualify only if they are designed as high-deductible plans, so check the plan details. You have until April 15, 2027, to contribute for 2026.


The one number that decides your subsidy

If you buy your own coverage on HealthCare.gov, the subsidy depends on your household income. For most families that is the adjusted gross income (AGI) on the tax return. Add tax-exempt interest, untaxed Social Security, and excluded foreign income if you have them.


Two rules matter in 2026:

  • Go one dollar over the line for your household size and the subsidy is zero.

  • If you took the subsidy during the year and finish over the line, you repay all of it.

Household size

Income line for 2026

1

$62,600

2

$84,600

3

$106,600

4

$128,600

5

$150,600

Below the line, lower income generally means a bigger subsidy. So the goal is simple: bring your AGI down.


Direct primary care

With direct primary care, you pay a doctor's office a flat monthly fee for routine visits instead of billing insurance. Here is what a membership means in 2026:

  • It no longer blocks an HSA. That holds as long as the fee is no more than $150 a month ($300 if it covers more than one person) and the membership covers only primary care.

  • You can pay the fee from your HSA, tax-free.

  • It does not replace a health plan. You still need a plan for hospitals, specialists and prescriptions, and you still need an HSA-eligible plan to have an HSA. A standard silver plan plus a membership does not qualify.

  • The fee does not count toward your plan's deductible.

  • The fee itself does not lower your AGI. The HSA contribution does.


A pairing that works: a bronze plan for the big bills, a membership for routine care, and an HSA that pays the membership fee and your out-of-pocket costs.


Think you made too much this year?

You can still bring your 2026 income down. Start at the top of this list.

  1. Fund an HSA. Up to $4,400, or $8,750 for family coverage. Deadline: April 15, 2027.

  2. Contribute to a Traditional IRA. Up to $7,500, or $8,600 if you are 50 or older. Deadline: April 15, 2027. The deduction shrinks at higher incomes if you have a retirement plan at work.

  3. Raise your pre-tax 401(k) contributions at work. Up to $24,500, plus $8,000 if you are 50 or older. It has to go through payroll by December 31. Roth contributions do not count.

  4. Self-employed? Use a solo 401(k) or SEP IRA. The business contribution can go in after the year ends, up to your tax filing deadline, so you can see your final income first. The next section shows how much you can put in and walks through an example.

  5. Push optional income into next year. Hold off on stock sales, Roth conversions and large retirement withdrawals until January.


What does not help: the standard deduction, itemized deductions, the 20% business income deduction, and the new deductions for tips, overtime and car loan interest. They lower your tax but not the income the Marketplace counts.


If you are self-employed

Business owners have the most room to bring income down, and the solo 401(k) is the best tool for it.


How much can go into a solo 401(k)

You contribute twice, once as the employee and once as the employer. For 2026:

  • As the employee: up to $24,500, plus $8,000 if you are 50 or older, or $11,250 if you are 60 to 63.

  • As the employer: about 20% of your net self-employment earnings if you are a sole proprietor, or 25% of your W-2 wages if you run an S corporation.

  • Together: no more than $72,000 before the extra amounts for age 50 and up.


For a sole proprietor under 50, that works out to roughly:

Net self-employment earnings

Employee

Employer

Total

$50,000

$24,500

$10,000

$34,500

$100,000

$24,500

$20,000

$44,500

$150,000

$24,500

$30,000

$54,500

$200,000

$24,500

$40,000

$64,500

A worked example

A Westfield couple with two kids runs a consulting business as a sole proprietorship. They buy the benchmark plan for $24,000 a year and deduct the premiums.


Before

After

Business income on the tax return

$164,000

$164,000

Solo 401(k) contribution

$0

$23,250

Health insurance deduction

$24,000

$12,750

Household income

$140,000

$128,000

Subsidy

$0

about $11,250

They start $11,400 over the $128,600 line for a family of four. Closing the gap takes more than $11,400. Once they qualify for a subsidy they pay less in premiums, so their premium deduction shrinks and their income moves back up. A contribution of about $23,250 gets them to $128,000.


Their solo 401(k) can take about $57,300, so there is plenty of room. And the $23,250 is still theirs, sitting in a retirement account.


Hiring your spouse

If your spouse does real work in the business, you can put them on payroll and add them to the solo 401(k). That buys a second employee contribution: up to $24,500 more, plus $8,000 if they are 50 or older. The business can also contribute up to 25% of their wages.

Two things to know. Their pay has to be at least as much as they contribute, and payroll taxes apply to it. The wages alone do not lower your household income, because they land on the same joint return. The retirement contribution is what helps.


Hiring your kids

Wages you pay your child for real work are a business expense, so they come off your income. If the child earns $16,100 or less in 2026 and has no investment income, the child does not have to file a federal tax return, and those wages do not come back into your household income.

  • Each $16,100 you pay takes roughly $15,000 off your household income.

  • In a sole proprietorship, wages paid to your child under 18 are not subject to Social Security and Medicare tax.

  • The work has to be real and the pay reasonable for the job. Keep time records.


More on this in Hiring Your Kids in Your Business: The Complete 2026 Tax Guide for Indiana Families.


What to do now

Open enrollment on HealthCare.gov runs through January 15, 2027. Enroll by December 15 for coverage that starts January 1.


A few thousand dollars of income on the wrong side of the line can cost you the whole subsidy. If you buy your own coverage, talk to us before December 31 and we will run your numbers.


  

This article is for general information and isn't tax advice for your specific situation. Schaaf CPA Group can help you evaluate whether this strategy fits your circumstances.

 

Schaaf CPA Accounting Logo 2

​Mon - Fri.  9 a.m. - 5 p.m. 

Saturday | Closed

Sunday | Closed

Schaaf CPA Group is located in downtown Westfield, Indiana

​

110 N Union St

Westfield, IN 46074

Join our mailing list

bottom of page